7 Comments

The labels and radio corporations have been crowding out new music with old stuff they already own since the late 1980s. We had to start a whole new "alternative" music industry then to get out from under their suffocating "Classic Rock" blockade; but then they bought that industry out too.

Nostalgia is now a weapon the past wields against the present and future; + a tool of devious marketing.

Never trust corporate appeals to it.

Expand full comment

Nervous Norvus lived for many years on Grand Avenue near Downtown Oakland. A true icon!

Expand full comment

I think part of the issue is that in, say 1995, it isn't easy for a song from 1977 to climb the charts. The charts were (I think?) largely derived from what plays on the top 40 radio stations. Top 40 generally wasn't going to play "Dreams" in 1995. Even if they got some requests for it.

Expand full comment

Hmm...well a lot of new music tries to pull from old genres. I heard it in Dua Lipa's Future Nostalgia pulling from disco and funk. The "Dreams" song was lucky to have a resurgence because of TikTok.

Expand full comment

I assume that “from 2010” doesn’t include much “remastered in 2010”

Expand full comment

Great analysis. How much of that 20% of pre-2010 songs streamed is holiday songs? What percent of all music listened to today is not going through an accounted revenue stream?

Expand full comment

I'm not sure it necessarily is a problem - but that people can access songs and great albums that they maybe were unable to in the 70s. If we had Spotify in the 70s for example, I imagine we still would have had new music in the 80s and 90s! I can go back and hear my dad's favorite music and have a better understanding of the context and time period than ever before.

Plus, I wonder how much of the data from the 70s is correct given that most music would have already been owned. Sales of music from the 50s wouldn't be captured, because grandpa owned them already or was past a point in life from buying new music - that again, he may not be if he had a spotify.

Also so many new bands have such great genre bending music because of this access! New inspiration beyond the radio!

Expand full comment