35 Comments
User's avatar
Nathan Self's avatar

As a longtime, somewhat reluctant, user of ultimate guitar I will say that often the chord annotations are not high quality. For instance, some annotators will have chord diagrams that show a voicing that actually rings out as e.g. Dsus4 but label it as D and use D throughout. Even more prevalent is songs where there are actually suspensions or extensions but which are written as plain major/minor throughout. I'm assuming Chordonomicon doesn't correct for this.

I don't think this changes your analysis (except maybe for rap? jazzy/laid back rap beats usually sound suspended/major 7th-y to me). I think it's interesting that this data is (likely) messy in a very domain-specific way.

Expand full comment
Chris Dalla Riva's avatar

That’s a good point but I’d be surprised if those errors were not equally distributed across genres and time

Expand full comment
Tony Fletcher's avatar

I was going to post individually about how this study is both fascinating and yet its results are largely unsurprising. (E.g. jazz features 7th chords more than rock; as jazz's popularity has declined, so has the 7th chord. Or: If G is the most popular chord, it stands to musical reason that C, D, A, and F would follow, pretty much in that order.)

But Nathan here raises an important point. Much of what is on Ultimate Guitar is patently inaccurate, and a hefty amount of it over-simplified by well-meaning amateurs posting their baby steps at training their musical ears... It is not the reliable sample set one should be drawing from. Also, multiple songs on Ultimate Guitar have multiple interpretations and I can tell you from experience that the ones with highest star ratings are often NOT the most accurate. Short of reading the authors' paper (which states 666,000 songs not 680,000) it's difficult to sense how they may have compensated for these factors; would they have included all six chord-sequences reported on a single hit record, or did they only go for the most popular of the six, without studying for accuracy?

I really appreciate what you did hear Chris and not trying to knock it, but when you make the point just above, about these errors of over-simplification being presumed as equally distributed across genres and time I might come back with a different theory/suggestion... Those who transcribe(d) complex jazz or fusion-rock or similarly complicated genres may well be more musical, better trained, older too, and therefore accurate in their transcriptions than those who post over-simplified transcriptions of contemporary pop.rock.r&b etc songs, where those suspended 4ths, minor 7ths and often enough, the simple difference between a major and a minor, all goes unreported. Additionally, to the notion that music has become less complex over time, not necessarily going to argue that; however, again given the sample study is being drawn from an amateur database to begin with, is it possible that older songs have more source material to be reported accurately, whereas newer songs are dependent on new transcriptions with less opportunity to revise?

Thanks any which way!~

Tony

Expand full comment
D.N. Stoddart's avatar

Since it's common knowledge among guitarists that Ultimate Guitar is not reliable for annotations, where should we go to get quality annotations, any tips or tricks?

Expand full comment
Nathan Self's avatar

I would say that Songsterr has better quality annotations on average. Back in the day there was a site called power tab archive that was doing a Wikipedia style approach: ultimate guitar but with peer review. It was awesome but shut down by RIAA

Expand full comment
Gustavo Meneses's avatar

Unfortunately, unless the producers or creators of the song release a full sheet of the music, you would have to rely on yours or other's ears to accurately map out the chords used. I am sure there are softwares that try to simplify this.

But in the end, you would still be relying on others. I recommend training your own ear to this capacity as it can be quite an awesome hobby to figure out songs on your own.

Expand full comment
BIG BALLS MAN's avatar

If you're not great with pitch like me, you can use sonic visualizer and annotate the spectogram is my best bet if you want a more definitive answer. But depending on the mix, it isn't always as easy.

Expand full comment
Gustavo Meneses's avatar

Unfortunately, unless the producers or creators of the song release a full sheet of the music, you would have to rely on yours or other's ears to accurately map out the chords used. I am sure there are softwares that try to simplify this.

But in the end, you would still be relying on others. I recommend training your own ear to this capacity as it can be quite an awesome hobby to figure out songs on your own.

Expand full comment
Christian's avatar

Very interesting.

A note on the jazz graph is that 9ths, 11ths and 13ths are very low. This may be because they are rarely notated and more often their use is left to the player. Basically any modern jazz chord is usually played with a couple of extensions.

Expand full comment
ben's avatar

That’s certainly true in jazz, but not necessarily in other popular music. Correctly transcribed Bowie songs, for example, would certainly have to notate the exact extensions.

Expand full comment
Timothy Nisly's avatar

Very interesting. I wonder if the tool accounts for capo-ing (especially if it's pulling from ultimate guitar), and what that would mean for the findings if so

Expand full comment
Chris Dalla Riva's avatar

Good point. I have no idea. Though luckily that wouldn’t affect the different groups of chords (ie a 7th chord is a 7th chord no matter where you capo)

Expand full comment
Rick Massimo's avatar

I find this stuff fascinating. I wonder how much the decline of the 7th chord is a function of guitar supplanting piano (which of course also a function of rock taking over from jazz).

Expand full comment
History Explored's avatar

This is great! I loved it, very thoughtful, original, and totally compelling for any guitar nerd 🫡👍👏

Expand full comment
Chris Dalla Riva's avatar

Thank you!

Expand full comment
ben's avatar

Interesting stuff; thanks for writing it. But I’m curious why your analysis wasn’t about the roles or functions of chords (e.g. I, V, Vm, etc) to be independent of key, rather than as “absolute” chords. A G can play a very different role depending on the tonic!

Expand full comment
Chris Dalla Riva's avatar

Mostly just because the dataset didn’t note the key. Because of that there was no reliable way to assess relative positions. Had that been part of the data, I probably would have done that

Expand full comment
PTBirnam's avatar

Ben — Yes, as in a G chord played in the key of B. Example:

G major, A major, B major.

This produces a strong chord pattern especially when used at the end of a chorus.

Pop songs that begin in the vi chord (A minor) but for most of the song the key is in C.

I find the Comments as informative as the article here.

Expand full comment
Mark Arnest's avatar

As a long-time jazz player, I have to question the accuracy of the data. I've played many more seventh chords than pure triads in my lifetime, and chord charts don't necessarily reflect musical practice: For instance, when a jazz player sees a tonic C chord on a chart, that's basically shorthand for C maj7, and a G chord in a song in C would almost automatically become G7. An analysis of the Real Book charts would be far more illuminating. Best of all, of course, would be harmonic analysis of actual performances.

Expand full comment
Ray Castro's avatar

One offramp to take from this piece is to track harmonic structure of popular music with the advent of affordable electronic keyboards. Especially in light of the popularity of rap. When you consider the way sampling was/is used, and the exposure to those older records, you're guaranteed to have certain sounds and harmonic patterns imprinted. With the ease of use of keyboards, I think there would be trends showing. And just due to the way the instrument is laid out, the most novice musician will find voicings different from guitar.

I would recommend watching Rick Beato's YouTube. One of the things he does is find the chords that get buried in today's popular music, due to it's emphasis on rhythm. Some tunes actually have interesting chords-if you are willing to scrape the paint and lacquer off them.

Expand full comment
AJDeiboldt-The High Notes's avatar

From a songwriting perspective, there are chord progressions that are just easier to come up with compelling melodies over than others, usually they consist of I vi IV V chords in some sequence. Once you start throwing in stuff in between those, you have to take that into account with your melody which can make it less intuitive. And if you're writing for a pop audience, the easier it is to sing, the better.

Expand full comment
El Duderino's avatar

Interesting article. Point though, some very repetitive songs will score high in imaginativeness. Think of Funk - 1 chord for the whole song would score 100%.

Am thinking of songs like James Brown’s “cold sweat”, “Shake everything you’ve got” by Maceo Parker (2 chords, 5 changes), or “straight cold player” by Lenny Kravitz, which has 2 chords and 3 changes, so 66%, that’s if you count the first chord (from no chord to a chord) as a change.

On the other side it means a song must be very imaginative to manage with so few chord changes. But they sure are repetitive.

And I wonder if such songs even show up in that database because one would probably describe them in tabs.

Does Funk count against Jazz?

Expand full comment
PTBirnam's avatar

Adding “Who Do You Love?” by Bo Diddley to the list of one-chord songs.

Expand full comment
John Rice's avatar

What percentage of songs consist of three majors and a minor? (G,C,D,Em) I have a theory that the reason so many songs follow this pattern is because it’s representative of life. There’s a buildup, a peak, a setback, and recovery that is a common cycle in life

Expand full comment
Tracy's avatar

Hi, is it possible to get a list of the 200 most common chords across all songs?

Expand full comment
Harrison Chapin's avatar

Love this! I’m Harrison, an ex fine dining industry line cook. My stack "The Secret Ingredient" adapts hit restaurant recipes (mostly NYC and L.A.) for easy home cooking. Dm me if interested in a recommendation swap — we’re growing fast!

check us out:

https://thesecretingredient.substack.com

Expand full comment
Wojtek's avatar

It would be nice to see the chord progression/patterns that are most commonly used in music . Like 251 or 145 etc. Can you do that?

Expand full comment
Wojtek's avatar

it would be great to see chords progression - sequence to see what patterns are most popular. can you do that?

Expand full comment
Linda Brady's avatar

Utterly fascinating. Thank you.

Expand full comment